Sugarloaf Key, FL Real Estate

Sugarloaf Key FL Real Estate Overview




Open Houses


Short Sales







Sugarloaf Key FL Real Estate Stats

Average Price in Sugarloaf Key: $1,211,034 / County Average: $1,160,883

Average Taxes in Sugarloaf Key: $5,416 / County Average: $5,651

Average Cost Per Sqr Ft in Sugarloaf Key: $602 / County Average: $625

Average Walkscore in Sugarloaf Key: 5 / County Average: 31

Average Year Built in Sugarloaf Key: 1989 / County Average: 1983

Average Days on Website in Sugarloaf Key: 137 / County Average: 156

Sugarloaf Key FL Real Estate Market Health

Neighborhoods in Sugarloaf Key FL

Indian Mound Estates Orchid Park Sub Perez Sub
Sugarloaf Acres Sugarloaf Beach Sugarloaf Shores
Sugarloaf Shores Sec F Rev Vacation Harbor

Areas in Sugarloaf Key FL

5940 Bay Point to Sugarloaf

Most Popular Listing

Popular Sugarloaf Key Real Estate

Most Expensive Listing

Expensive Sugarloaf Key Real Estate

Least Expensive Listing

Cheap Sugarloaf Key Real Estate

Listings in Sugarloaf Key

A castle on the ocean's edge, this home was built for privacy, tranquility, safety and--above all--abundant riches of water access...

Just reduced! don't miss showing your buyers this home...

This completely custom open water home in sugarloaf shores boasts over 400' of waterfront where you can enjoy keys famous sunsets over sugarloaf sound...

Loved and cared for as a primary home, recently updated and move in ready...

Magnificent oceanfront home offers serenity & priv...

Quintessential florida keys living in sugarloaf shores...

Priced to sell! this home is immaculate and beautifully designed offering unlimited water views in all directions for spectacular sunrises and sets...

This gorgeous 3.5 acre oceanfront compound boasts a 3 br 2 ba beachfront main residence plus 2 beachfront 2 bedroom guest cottages all located on one of the prettiest beaches the keys have to offer...

-acre pool home with separate 1 br guest house on Sugarloaf Key. this beautiful home is ready for you to mo...

Waterfront new construction on Sugarloaf Key!! this 3 bd/2 ba 1,620 sq...

make gorgeous colorful open water views in a peaceful private setting yours on one of the most desirable parcels in south point in Sugarloaf Key. call today! owner is a licensed florida realtor....

Wide open spaces! one acre with amazing open water views...

Beautiful custom pool home located on one of the quietest streets in desirable sugarloaf shores...

open water views and protected dockage with this Sugarloaf Key home. wake ...

This sugarloaf home has two bedrooms and two bathrooms and includes a workshop enclosure under the house...

Beautiful sugarloaf shores location! open water views...

Just reduced $200,000 for quick sale! a must see. this home is immaculate and beautifully designed, offering unlimited water views in all directions for spectacular sunrises and sets...

Irma damaged home for sale as is. over sized lot with 3/2 on east side canal so no bridges to go under...

Hurricane irma distress sale. custom designed 2,020 sf 3 br home boasting 180 degree sunset views over sugarloaf sound...

Gorgeous sunset views over sugarloaf sound from this meticulously maintained 3 bedroom 2...

Property Search

Saved Properties

This is a list of your favorite properties. We will email you if a property is reduced or leaves the market.

Click 'Save' to add a property to this list.

Register / Login

New & returning visitors please enter your information to login.

By clicking 'register' you are agreeing to our terms of use & giving us expressed written consent to contact you.

Questions? Comments? Complaints?

This message will go directly to the head of our team.

Stella Cogno